Mine Safety Training Repository
united states mine rescue association
Mine Disasters in the United States

Tank's Poetry

Father Time
See more disasters
from this year
Calendar Image
Mine Disaster Calendar

Plateau Mining Company
Starpoint No. 1 Mine Roof Fall

Wattis, Carbon County, Utah
August 24, 1979
No. Killed - 4

MSHA Final Investigation Report  (884 Kb)  PDF Format


On Friday, August 24, 1979, at 10:45 a.m., a fall of roof occurred in a pillar split on the 1st north section of the Starpoint No. 1 mine.  The accident resulted in fatal injuries to William H. Gentry, Jr., section foreman, Michael S. Guzman, continuous mining machine helper, Tim L. Nightingale, roof bolting machine operator, Kerry Ray Grange, bratticeman, and serious injuries to Alan L. Austin, continuous mining machine operator.  The roof fall occurred while preparing to install posts in a pillar split.  The accident occurred because mine management failed to comply with the approved roof control plan.

Retreat mining was underway in the Starpoint No. 1 Mine on August 23 and 24, 1979.  This operation involved excavating coal from a pillar located between the No. 3 entry and a caved-in area in the No. 2 entry.

By the evening of August 23, the split had advanced about 20 feet beyond the last row of roof bolts.  Nevertheless, the newly exposed roof was not bolstered with additional roof bolts.

On the midnight shift of August 24, the split was lengthened further, with the newest sections of the split featuring a right fork and a left fork.  While the split was being advanced, the operator's compartment of the continuous mining machine was moved about 15 feet beyond the last row of roof bolts - a violation of roof support regulations.

By about 10:45 a.m. on August 24 the continuous mining machine had been returned to an area supported by roof bolts, and some timbers had been installed in the split.  As additional timbers were being prepared for installation, a sudden roof fall occurred.  The collapse killed four miners and seriously injured another.

MSHA investigators determined that the accident had been caused by violations of the roof control plan, including failure to follow the approved cut sequence, and faulty pillar recovery methods that produced excessive widths.

Historical Summary of Mine Disasters in the United States, Volume II

See more about these products